'The Substance': What Would You Be Willing to Do to Be Young Again?

PREMIERE

"If you follow the instructions, what could go wrong?" This seemingly simple question guides the downward spiral of The Substance, a film that not only explores the desire for youth but also delves into the deep shadows of identity, self-esteem, and alienation in modern culture.

The Illusion of Eternal Youth
The plot centers on a black-market drug that allows the user to replicate their youthful appearance—a younger, more desirable version of themselves. In a world where fame and success seem inextricably tied to youth, The Substance raises uncomfortable questions about self-image and the value society places on appearances. As the protagonist experiences this temporary rejuvenation, we witness her growing disconnection from reality and from her true self. What begins as a simple attempt to recapture an idealized version of herself quickly spirals into horror.

What stands out here is how the film plays with the notion of self-esteem. It’s easy, when you’re young, to say that you should accept who you are, but The Substance challenges that security. Moore, in her role, embodies this inner struggle, confronting the social and personal pressure to hold onto something that is already gone. The script forces you to reflect: as we age, how much are we willing to sacrifice to avoid the inevitable passage of time? The film’s reflection back at us is uncomfortable, like a distorted version of our own collective insecurity.

Hypersexualization and Social Critique
The use of hypersexualization in The Substance is far from gratuitous. The younger version of the protagonist, portrayed by Margaret Qualley, is a hypersexualized, almost surreal figure—a fantasy product embodying what the industry expects from her. This contrast between Moore’s real and idealized versions highlights the film's commentary on how women are viewed and treated in the entertainment industry. What at first seems like an exaggeration soon reveals its thematic coherence: the film needs this visual treatment to expose the cruelty of a society that fetishizes superficiality.

The body and image are treated as consumable products, both for the audience and for the protagonist herself. It’s not just a critique of Hollywood culture but also a reflection of how youth and physical attractiveness have become currency in all aspects of modern life.

Echoes of King Kong
The parallel with King Kong becomes clear in the final moments of the film. The protagonist, now fully transformed and out of control, becomes a monster for the very society that had once lifted her up as an icon. Like the great ape brought into civilization only to be taken down, the protagonist of The Substance succumbs to the same forces that once elevated her. Her fall is tragic, and the society that once celebrated her devours her without mercy.

The final scene, where the protagonist dies on her Hollywood Walk of Fame star, is particularly devastating. That star, once a symbol of her success, becomes her grave—a reminder that fame and youth are fleeting and ultimately destructive.

We live until we are no longer remembered.

@LOVACAINE